|ShilNepal Editorial
Nepal Shilajit ShilNepal container on marble

Supplement shops are easy to copy. A convincing website, a professional photo of a tin and a few five-star reviews take an afternoon to fake, and the sales season is when scammers are busiest. This guide is for anyone in Australia about to buy a supplement online, from us or anyone else. It covers how to check that a shop is real, how to pay, what the law says about your rights, and what to do if it goes wrong.

Key takeaways

  • Scamwatch's warning signs are consistent: unusually low prices, no terms and conditions, ABN or privacy policy, only vague positive reviews, and unusual payment requests.
  • A .com.au address is not proof of anything. Scamwatch notes fake stores copy real brands and can use Australian-looking domains.
  • Pay by credit card or PayPal where possible. Instant bank payments are hard to recover.
  • Australian Consumer Law applies when an overseas business sells directly to consumers in Australia, but the ACCC says enforcing your rights against it can be difficult.

Why it matters in sale season

Black Friday and Cyber Monday fall in the last week of November, and Scamwatch has warned about fake online stores at this time of year before. Its 2023 Black Friday alert counted 2,760 reports of fake online stores and more than half a million dollars in losses for that year to that point. That is historical, but the pattern has not gone away. In a December 2024 alert, Scamwatch said about 50 per cent of the fake or malicious websites taken down in the previous three months had been running online shopping scams.

You do not need to be paranoid. You need a short routine you run every time you buy from a shop you have not used before.

Ten checks before you pay

These are drawn from Scamwatch's own lists of warning signs and protection tips. Run as many as you can. One failed check is a reason to slow down, and several is a reason to leave.

# Check What a real shop usually shows What should worry you
1 Price In line with other sellers of the same thing An unbelievably low price, or a famous brand at a bargain price
2 Business details A named business, an ABN, terms and conditions, a privacy policy None of these on the site
3 ABN An ABN that checks out on ABN Lookup and matches the business name No ABN, or one that belongs to a different business
4 Contact page A way to reach a person, and an address that exists on a map No contact details, or an address that leads nowhere
5 Reviews Detailed, mixed in tone, on independent sites as well as the shop's own Only positive reviews with little detail
6 Search the name Searching the shop name plus "review" or "scam" finds real discussion Nothing at all, or a trail of complaints
7 Web address A clean address that matches the brand Extra dashes or symbols, or a look-alike spelling of a known brand
8 Domain age Registered some time ago, which you can check with ICANN Lookup, or auDA WHOIS for .com.au Registered very recently, with a big social media advertising push
9 How you found it You searched for the shop yourself You clicked a pop-up, an email link or a social media ad
10 Payment options Credit card, PayPal or another secure payment service Bank transfer, money order, pre-loaded card or several different PayIDs

Two of these deserve a closer look. First, search results are not a guarantee. Scamwatch says scammers pay for fake sites to appear at the top of search results, so the first listing may not be the real shop. Second, a .com.au address proves little. Scamwatch's Black Friday alert says fake sites can use stolen logos, professional designs, a .com.au domain and even a stolen ABN. That is why the contact check and the independent reviews matter as much as the ABN.

How you pay matters

Scamwatch's advice on payment is blunt: pay by PayPal or credit card, and avoid direct bank deposits, money transfers and digital currency. It also suggests keeping a second credit card with a low limit just for online shopping.

The reason is recovery. Scamwatch notes that many payments are now instant, and it is unlikely you will get your money back from an instant transfer. The ACCC adds that a credit card provider may reverse a charge if the product never arrives, though time limits can apply, and that payment services such as PayPal may refund in some situations depending on their own terms. Neither is a promise, but both are better odds than a bank transfer to a stranger.

If you pay by PayID or bank transfer to a private seller, check that the name on the account matches the name of the person or business you think you are paying.

Your rights, including overseas sellers

Under the Australian Consumer Law, consumers automatically receive consumer guarantees when they buy goods and services, and the ACCC says a business cannot take those basic rights away by anything it says or does. That includes the small print on a website.

For overseas sellers, the ACCC's position is specific. When an overseas business sells products directly to consumers in Australia, it must follow the Australian Consumer Law, including the consumer guarantees. There is a limit. Consumers are not covered if the business does not officially offer its products in Australia. The ACCC's example is a product sent to an overseas address that you then have forwarded to Australia yourself.

The same page is honest about the practical problem: it can be difficult to get a repair, replacement or refund from an overseas business, and help from Australian consumer protection agencies is limited. If you are choosing between two similar shops, one in Australia and one overseas, that difficulty is a fair reason to prefer the local one.

Extra checks for supplements

A supplement is something you put in your body, so it deserves a few questions a t-shirt does not.

  • 1Is there a batch number on the product or listing, and can the seller point you to a lab report for that batch? See how to read a product label.
  • 2Does the report name the laboratory, and can you read what was actually tested? See how to read a lab test report.
  • 3Does the shop promise results for health conditions? Treat that as a reason for caution rather than a selling point.
  • 4Are delivery and returns terms written down, and do the pages agree with each other?

If something goes wrong

Scamwatch's guidance for anyone who has been caught is to act quickly.

  • Contact your bank straight away if money has gone or you shared card details.
  • Call IDCARE on 1800 595 160 if you gave out personal information.
  • Report the scam to Scamwatch at scamwatch.gov.au, which helps protect other people.
  • Report to police through cyber.gov.au.
  • Change passwords if any may have been exposed, and watch your bank statements.

FAQ

Is a website with a .com.au address safe?

Not by itself. Scamwatch says fake sites can use a .com.au domain and even a stolen ABN, so combine the address check with the contact details, independent reviews and the payment method.

What is the safest way to pay an online shop?

Scamwatch recommends PayPal or a credit card, and advises against direct bank deposits, money transfers and digital currency.

Do Australian consumer guarantees apply to overseas websites?

The ACCC says they do when an overseas business sells directly to consumers in Australia. They do not when the business does not officially offer its products in Australia, for example when you have a parcel forwarded yourself.

How can I check an ABN?

Scamwatch points to ABN Lookup on business.gov.au, where you can confirm the ABN is real and belongs to the business you think you are buying from.

Sources

  1. Scamwatch (ACCC). Buying and selling scams. scamwatch.gov.au/types-of-scams/buying-and-selling-scams. No date shown on the page.
  2. Scamwatch (ACCC). Scam alert: Online shopping scams. 4 December 2024.
  3. Scamwatch (ACCC). Shopping for online bargains this Black Friday weekend? Make sure it's the real deal. 20 November 2023.
  4. Scamwatch (ACCC). Stop. Check. Protect. scamwatch.gov.au/protect-yourself.
  5. ACCC. Consumer rights and guarantees, and Buying online. accc.gov.au/consumers/buying-products-and-services. Sections on products from overseas businesses.

This is general information, not legal or financial advice. Scam guidance changes, so check Scamwatch for the current version.

Related Reading